The following listings have been distilled from recent
full-length reviews; the date appearing at the end of each entry indicates the
month and year of review. Hours, credit-card and liquor information are not
included, so be sure to call ahead. And bear in mind that some
menus change seasonally.
DON JOSé TEQUILAS, 351
Atwells Ave., Providence (454-8951). Re-opening in April after an absence of
nearly a year, this Mexican restaurant has relocated from Olneyville to Federal
Hill. The decor is fancier, with dangling ivy and walls sponge-painted papaya,
but there's still the stray sombrero and serape. Like the setting, the menu has
been upscaled a bit, though not so much the prices. For example, a special of
pan-fried rainbow trout in white wine, lemon and butter -- the Mexican touch
being cilantro -- was $11.95. Among the appetizers, we had a sampler, the
aperitivo especial ($8.95), which has a variety of treats, including wedges of
cheese and chicken tacos. There's a choice of soups: beef, vegetable, seafood,
and a daily special, each $5.95. Most traditional items are available, from
burritos to enchiladas -- not to mention "steamed goat shanks in guajillo
sauce." Interesting daily items on a recent visit included sautéed
shrimp in an orange and tequila cream sauce; and chicken breast stuffed with
chorizo, a poblano chile and cheese, under mole sauce ($11.95 each). Don Jose
roast pork ($10.95) is marinated in chicken broth, evaporated milk and tequila,
and it's as flavorful as it sounds. All entrées come with a loose
preparation of mashed beans, plus Spanish rice, and ours also had small
shredded salads on the plates. The kitchen-made desserts, none more than $3,
include carrot cake, and fresh papaya in a caramelized sauce. The flan is
cooked long enough here to have a creamier consistency than most others.
Delicious. And don't forget to ask about the off-the-menu ceviche. (8/00)(7/00)
FISH STORIES, 629 Succotash Road, East Matunuck (789-2864). Summer visitors
come to South County for the surf and the sand, but they stick around for a
good cup o' chowdah, a few "stuffies" and a cold beer at the end of the day. A
newcomer to the seafood scene, Fish Stories offers all three and much more.
Just up the road from East Matunuck State Beach, Fish Stories has glorious
views of the water and wildlife from the dining room's back tables. The seafood
here is either grilled (with a choice of four marinades), baked (with or
without stuffing) or sautéed (in white or red sauces). Clams zuppa
($5.95), littlenecks in red or white sauce (we chose white), and sautéed
calamari ($5.95), are a good way to start. The littlenecks were tasty, with
plenty of garlic in the sauce (great for dipping our bread), and the calamari
was similarly good. Other appealing choices include grilled tuna salad ($8.95)
and jerk shrimp salad ($9.95). Seafood cioppino ($12.95), with clams, mussels,
scallops and shrimp, had a tasty sauce and the scallops were just right,
although the clams, mussels and shrimp seemed a little over-cooked. Stuffed
flounder ($10.95), featured chunks of real crabmeat in the stuffing and creamy
lobster sauce on top, along with sides of pan-fried red bliss potato slices and
mixed summer vegetables. Most desserts at Fish Stories are not house-made, so
we tried one that was: strawberry shortcake ($4.50). It featured a delicious
pound-cake and a balsamic treatment that mysteriously brought out the sweetness
of the strawberries. (8/00)
OLYMPIA TEA ROOM, 74 Bay St., Watch Hill (348-8211). Boasting a sea view and
located between shopping spree temptations, this distinctive destination has
been pretty popular since it opened in 1916. Outside tables allow for up-close
people watching, and the usual breeze off of Block Island Sound provides
nature's own air conditioning. Inside, the ambiance is '50s soda
fountain-meets-Henri Rousseau. Culinary imagination is also in evidence. Among
the appetizers, grilled scallops ($8.50) come on fried greens with wasabi;
liver and onions ($15.95) is offered as a bravely nostalgic comfort-food
opportunity. Among entrees, the baked and stuffed Point Judith one-pound
lobster ($23) had crab and small shrimp in a buttery stuffing, and was cooked
to perfection: just barely done, and thereby sweet and juicy. Calamari Olympia
($16.50), featured tender local squid and a flavorful topping with tomatoes,
peppers and calamata olives, although the linguini was past al dente. The tea
room's half-dozen desserts are worth a trip by themselves. Priced from
$4.50-$6, they span the indulgence spectrum from Key lime pie and griddled
pound cake to rum-soaked ginger bread, and chocolate cake topped with fudge
sauce. Although summer is when most people discover or revisit the Olympia Tea
Room (it's packed during the hot weather), it will remain open this year until
January. (8/00)