Unbearably good
Nathan Englander's stunning Urges
by John Freeman
FOR THE RELIEF OF UNBEARABLE URGES. By Nathan Englander. Knopf, 206 pages, $22.
Bernard Malamud and Philip Roth won the 1959 and 1960
National Book Awards for their first story collections, The Magic Barrel
and Goodbye, Columbus, respectively, and it will be no surprise if
Nathan Englander's debut repeats this award performance in 1999. It is not just
the clarity and virtuosity of Englander's stories that makes them outstanding.
It is Englander's voice, which comes to us bold, unwavering, and with a whiff
of prophecy that, like Roth's and Malamud's writing, expands the boundaries of
the story to near-hallucinatory vistas.
For the Relief of Unbearable Urges is populated by Jews of modest but
psychologically revealing vocation. Writers, rabbis, and unhappily married
women animate the book with their spiritual and sensual wrangling. Englander
brilliantly transforms his prose style -- choppy and severe in one instance,
languid and layered as an onion in the next -- to capture the rhythms of each
new world. The first lines of "The Wig," for example, convey the mix of
sensuality and rigidity with which Ruchama, an Orthodox Jewish wig maker, views
her world: "Colors and styles, she takes note of. Hemlines, accessories, heel
width and height. Also, that the girls get taller every month, bonier and more
sickly looking. Ruchama had quite a figure herself as a girl, kept it until the
first three children were born. But never, from the age of twelve, was she
without a chest and a bottom. She really can't imagine how these fence posts
manage to sit down." Early in the story, it is clear that Ruchama (who is not
past 50) has chosen (or been chosen by) her profession to recapture part of her
youth. From its outset, the story funnels toward Ruchama's fantasy -- to be a
woman stopping traffic with a mane of hair -- and her eventual brutal encounter
with reality.
Many of Englander's characters live, like Ruchama, in a state of
hyperconsciousness that is a blend of piety and lunacy. Like Dostoyevsky's
characters, they are so devoted to their idea of faith that it makes them
outcasts. In "The Gilgul of Park Avenue," an unassuming WASP named Charles
Morton Louger discovers, as he rides uptown in a cab, that he has a Jewish
soul. ("Ping! Like that it came. Like a knife against a glass.") His wife does
not like this development at all, so he goes to the Royal Hills Mystical Jewish
Reclamation Center and speaks with a rabbi from Bolinas, California -- another
man who "suddenly" discovered his Jewish soul. When Louger gets his rabbi,
shrink, and wife together, the outcome is anything but resolution.
In "Reunion," an on-again, off-again mental patient named Marty meets a John
Doe while recuperating in a mental hospital. Marty decides to help Doe both get
better and reunite with his rabbi brother. Two trips to Brooks Brothers and a
regimen of medication later, they crash a party at the house of the rabbi, who
shoves Doe into the street, telling him to "Go . . . back
to your gutter. Take your fancy clothes and get away." Again and again,
characters rap their heads against a world that is comically and tragically
indifferent to their deepest desires. As the Bolinas-born rabbi says: "There is
no hope for the pious."
Throughout the volume, in fact, the fate of the pious is harsh and seemingly
illogical. As Malamud wrote in his classic story "The Jewbird": "The window was
open so the skinny bird flew in. Flappity-flap with its frazzled black wings.
That's how it goes. It's open, you're in. Closed, you're out, and that's your
fate." Showing how characters face the grimmest of fates is the basis for
Englander's three finest stories. In "The Twenty-Seventh Man," a clerical error
in Stalinist Russia mistakenly gets an aspiring writer named Pinchas Pelovitz
rounded up with 26 great Yiddish writers. It becomes clear that escaping is a
pipe dream and death, certain. Just as they go before the firing squad,
Pelovitz "publishes" his first story by reciting it to the group; being chosen
for death ironically legitimizes his presence among the others. In "The
Tumblers," followers of the Mahmir Rebbe escape a train to the death camps by
stumbling into a circus car. To make their escape, the Jews camouflage
themselves as acrobats and perform before an audience of Nazi sympathizers.
After a few magical moments when they almost become like acrobats, limber
enough to twist their way out of seemingly inevitable fates, they are heckled
by the audience, called "clumsy as Jews." Although they are spared death, the
humiliation is scarcely less imprisoning than a concentration camp. And in the
title story, a young man whose marital bed has gone cold gets a rabbi's
prescription to go to a prostitute. Yet the predictable "side effects" of the
treatment render him incapable of the love his wife is now ready for.
Englander asks us to be duplicitous readers -- in his stories we witness what
did not, but could have, occurred. In "The Twenty-Seventh Man" we are like the
28th man in the roundup, witnessing but not dying with the writers; in "The
Tumblers" we are privy to the Mahmirims' luck, and we must be complicit in
their bravery and humiliation; and in "The Wig" we share Ruchama's secret about
the wig, and the fantasy, she makes for herself. These stories boldly reimagine
what fiction is capable of doing. They go beyond escapism to engage us, and ask
us to share in the moral burden of their creation.