|
One begins to wonder whether Gwen Stefani is capable of having any fun. Pop tarts suffering nervous breakdowns in public are barely newsworthy, but committing one to tape on a highly leveraged solo debut is just plain weird. On LAMB (the title is but the first of the disc’s many plugs for her couture line), Gwen takes a holiday from No Doubt’s brand-name-rock responsibilities, but the clubby confection she promised never shows up. There’s a flash of what might have been on the first single and leadoff track, "What You Waiting For?" A self-scolding dialogue on the singer’s inability to finish the song she’s singing, it’s Gwen as an American Kylie Minogue, a globetrotting sophisticate dressed up in escapist electro-pop ear candy. But then everything goes awry. Dr. Dre’s Fiddler on the Roof–sampling "Rich Girl" falls flat, though as a Jewish-dancehall jingle, it’ll make a great Hanukkah single. (ND’s Tony Kanal actually does a better Dre impersonation on the quiet-storming R&B ballad "Luxurious," stapling Kayne-esque kettle-drum rolls to Turtle-waxed G-funk synth lines.) And though on "Hollaback Girl" Gwen promises "My shit is bananas," the Neptunes’ drum-line crunch merely bites the dust. Stefani’s lyrics have never been bad enough for anyone to notice, but they become a cringe-inducing embarrassment on "Harajuku Girls," and her creepy obsession with Japan’s hysteric-glamor underworld reappears throughout the album like a bad rash. She has a whimpering voice that takes easily to melancholia but is almost resistant to anything carefree. The exception that proves the rule is Andre 3000’s ode to back-seat education, "Bubble Pop Electric": Johnny Vulture sets the drum machine to ’86 Megadeth, the guitars on stun, and the bass-synths to "Hey Ya!," multi-tracking Gwen into ecstatic choruses that sound like Sandra Dee tickling a tubful of Andrews Sisters to the tune of "Paradise by the Dashboard Lights." Ultimately, of course, a voice like that can sell you just about anything. After almost every misstep, Stefani simply adopts that gorgeous Betty Boop–some pout, waves her magic wand, and coos a cheap knockoff of some ’80s club-nouveau anthem or designer-pop song you loved in the first place. And presto: a mediocre album it’s impossible to stay mad at. By Carly Carioli
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Issue Date: December 3 - 9, 2004 Back to the Music table of contents |
Sponsor Links | |||
---|---|---|---|
© 2000 - 2007 Phoenix Media Communications Group |