Providence's Alternative Source!
  Feedback


Paging George Santayana
BY PHILLIPE & JORGE

Your superior correspondents are big fans of the annual PU-litzer Prizes for idiotic journalistic achievement, which were recently awarded for 2001. Perhaps our favorite went to the home of one of our favorite chicks, Newsweek's Cathleen McGuigan, who had a sufficient sense of humor to circulate it to friends. Then again, she wasn't the guilty party.

As the PU-litzer committee described the gaffe, "When Newsweek published a December 3 cover story of George W. and Laura Bush, it was a paean to 'The First Team,' more akin to worship than journalism. Along the way, the magazine explained that the president doesn't read many books. 'He's busy making history, but doesn't look back at his own, or the world's . . . Bush would rather look forward than backward. It's the way he's built, and the result is a president who operates without evident remorse or second-guessing.' "

Yep, he looks out of a window in his stomach because he's got his head that far up his ass. It's the way he's built. Laura, will you read me some Harry Potter?

A reassuring answer

Nothing like taking a flight when the guy next to you tries to set fire to two fuses leading into the explosives in his sneakers, now is there?

Yes, Richard Reid (if that is indeed your name, Lieutenant Batguano), the rather deranged Brit (if that is indeed your nationality, Mr. bin Laden), caused quite a stir when he had to be subdued on a flight from Paris to Miami that was diverted to Boston - no doubt because of the renowned safety standards at Logan. But could there be anything lamer than the excuse offered by government spokesmodels, reported in the immediate aftermath by the Washington Post, to try to calm fears that yet another potentially fatal breach of security had occurred on a huge jetliner?

"Other government sources cautioned that the man -- identified by Boston authorities as Richard Reid -- could have simply been trying to light a cigarette with his shoes . . . " Well, there's an explanation that makes sense. You can keep those Zippo and Bic lighters. Just give us a good pair of Converse high-tops when we want to torch up a Gitane.

What an incredible organ

Our Little Towne lost a true original with the passing of Skip Chernov this past week. Regardless of whether he was posing nude for an alternative newspaper; starting a bar called the Incredible Organ; buying people Cadillacs, whistle blowing on corrupt public officials; or making outrageous claims, like saying he was seduced into selling a professional basketball team because he was drunk, but now wanted it back, you could count on Skip to be anything but boring. We'll be blaring "Stairway to Heaven" at Casa Diablo in memory of the old rock and roll promoter.

Merci beaucoup

This has not been the most delightful year in Phillipe and Jorge's life, so in retrospect we can appreciate even better the bright lights that appeared in it. As always, our sincerest thanks and praise to editors Ian Donnis and Lou Papineau for putting up with our BS and Butterfly McQueen-esque dramatics on a weekly basis. And also to all the people who are responsible for cranking out this rag every week. Special kudos to Steve Brown, the head ramrod of the Providence Phoenix, whose tireless work has allowed the paper to survive through the years. Also to Peter Kadzis, top editor at the Phoenix Media/Communications Group, whose shrewd editorial judgment has kept P&J out of jail for libel, and PM/CG owner Stephen Mindich, who recently said to your superior correspondents either, "Thank you for carrying the paper on the back of your vast talents," or, "You two are fucking morons." Memory does not serve well in this instance.

But most of all, thank you to all of our friends, many of whom saw at least P through a personal annus horribilus, and whose addresses range from Ten Rod Road and Albatross Drive to New York, New Orleans, L.A., and Paris. It won't be forgotten.

America and apple pie

If the pageant leaves Atlantic City, it would be a historical tragedy. They go together like America and apple pie. The values of the pageant would exist wherever they put it, but everybody would lose something." This, according to Vicki Gold Levi, former Miss America pageant judge and author (with Lee Eisenberg) of Atlantic City: 125 Years of Ocean Madness.

The Miss America Organization thinks that holding the pageant at Boardwalk Hall in Atlantic City is vital, and it's trying to pressure the city and the State of New Jersey into ponying up another million bucks in support. The Atlantic City Convention & Visitors Authority (which already kicks in $678,000) is balking at providing more cash. And so the Miss America people are threatening to move the operation to Vegas, Florida, or maybe even Mohegan Sun in nearby Connecticut. Perhaps it could take place on the under card of the next Vinnie Paz bout?

The whole imbroglio is as hilarious as the pageant itself of course. The caretakers of the Miss America legacy are always harping about the "image" of their contestants, but they somehow think that Vegas and/or an Indian casino will strike the right chord?

As local partisans, your superior correspondents would like the Renaissance City to place its bid for the pageant forthwith. It would be perfect for the Dunkin' Donuts Center, especially if they start opening up the competition to contestants who are, let's say, a bit more zaftig than in recent years.

Political correctness update

Aren't we all so relieved that Time magazine has backed off its proclaimed standards and practices, naming Mayor Rudy Giuliani as its "Person of the Year"? It was noted ad nauseam while the prospects were still being bandied about that previous designees included Hitler and Stalin. This is because, as Henry Luce originally laid it down, the Person (in those days "Man") of the Year was supposed to be the individual who most influenced our lives in the past 365 days. It was created not as an honor, but an objective assessment.

So your superior correspondents find it interesting that the conservative voices so often raised in opposition to "political correctness" are strangely silent in this case. Let's be honest. In any real analysis of the past year, one has to look to the evil perpetrated by bin Laden as the most influential event. Giuliani's heroic action was in his response to the attacks, without which he would be remembered more for his unfortunate marital strife, the ridiculous fights he picked in attempting to "cleanse" the art scene in New York, and a rather ambiguous legacy in race relations, as well as NYC's rise through the '90s.

But as with virtually everything, marketing wins the day in selecting the Person of the Year cover figure. While Time's managing editor, Jim Kelly, announced that bin Laden was rejected because he is "too small of a man to get the credit for all that has happened in America [since the attacks]", who does Kelly think is responsible? The US government seems to think that bin Laden is the primary culprit. Does Kelly have information suggesting otherwise?

When you consider Time's Person of the Year tradition, it's clear that bin Laden should have been selected. It's equally clear that he wasn't because of a classic example of "political correctness." Will we be hearing from the usual conservative pundits on this? Don't hold your breath.

Afghan opportunities

Yes, times are tough in the US of A right now, and because of this, Phillipe & Jorge are looking into opportunities in Afghanistan. Now that in many parts of the country the burkas are off and Western influence is bound to be flooding into the former Taliban stronghold, your superior correspondents imagine there could be some possible job opportunities opening up real soon. For instance, if P&J became editors of the Pashtun edition of Maxim or Details, we could probably give the folks over there a good idea of what like is like in the West. And, undoubtedly Martha Stewart will soon be heading in country to instruct the Northern Alliance on poppy arrangements.

The superior angle

The San Francisco Examiner broke the story that John Walker, the young American man captured with the Taliban, left home shortly after his father, Frank Lindh, had left Walker's mother and their family in 1997 to move in with another man. Ever since then, the Examiner and the other San Francisco daily, the Chronicle, have been swapping charges as to who's exploiting the Walker family. Implicit in the Chronicle's charge that the Examiner attacked the Walker family in a "disgusting" way is that there's something negative or insulting about noting that Mr. Lindh is gay.

That's a bit too much for these two superior behaviorists. The reason why the story may be important is in explaining the behavior of young Walker. The Examiner reported that he was bothered and confused by this change in the family dynamic. Could this explain something about his all-consuming interest in Islam and subsequent involvement with the Taliban, one of the most virulently anti-gay groups in the world, who wielded one of the most extreme interpretations of that faith?

It is not unusual for people who become deeply upset about something they don't understand to irrationally strike out against it (like a person upset by a parent's being Jewish getting hooked up with neo-Nazis). We're not psychiatrists, but we do know that the Examiner's story on the family of John Walker Lindh is part of the story and may explain much about our fears, ignorance, and how we deal with it, for better or worse.

Send instant decoder rings and Pulitzer-grade tips to p&j[a]phx.com.

Issue Date: December 28, 2001 - January 3, 2002


The P & J archives