GODS AND GENERALS
War may be Hell, but in this four-hour Civil War epic from Ronald
Maxwell, the syrupy monologues and righteous Bible thumping provide the
punishment. To its credit, Gods and Generals doesn't leave you
battle-weary, and the large-scale re-enactments and period sets (minus some
cheesy CGI effects) impress throughout. The film's biggest shortcoming is its
murky historical revisionism. Based on the novel by Jeff Shaara, this prequel
to Gettysburg (which was based on The Killer Angels, by Shaara's
late father, Michael) paints the North-South conflict as a blood feud between
Maine and Virginia, and it advances the dubious notion that a desire to
liberate the slaves was widespread among Southern leaders. Maxwell charts the
early years of the war through the exploits of Confederate strategist Thomas
"Stonewall" Jackson, who as played by Stephen Lang lifts the film above the
herky-jerky direction (Maxwell helmed Gettysburg with a much steadier
hand). Jeff Daniels returns as Lieutenant Colonel Joshua Chamberlain, and
Robert Duvall picks up a paycheck as General Robert E. Lee. It all makes for
high drama, but if you want the real thing, defer to Ken Burns's superb
(11-hour) documentary. (240 minutes) At the Flagship, Opera House, and
Showcase cinemas.
Issue Date: February 21 - 27, 2003
|