MAID IN MANHATTAN
As its title (a three-way pun, and the cleverest thing in the movie) suggests,
Maid in Manhattan is a product. Take the main ingredient, the fabulously
popular Jennifer Lopez, put her in a shoddy retread of the already shoddy
Pretty Woman, and add a cute little boy and a cute older boy and a few
cynical stabs at social consciousness. It should be a big hit, especially with
its moral that the poor and despised among us are just the same as the rich and
celebrated. After all, isn't J. Lo a little of both?
Here she's Marisa Ventura, a domestic at a swank Manhattan hotel where the
staff are encouraged to be "invisible." Shades of Ralph Ellison? Hardly. Marisa
has upwardly mobile ambitions, so it takes only a little arm twisting from a
co-worker to get her to try on a set of fancy duds discarded by a haughty guest
and so be mistaken for a guest herself by Senate candidate Christopher Marshall
(Ralph Fiennes). Director Wayne Wang, stung no doubt by the poor reception
given his NC-17 fit of boldness The Center of the World, tries to
freshen up this stinker through confusion and implausibility. It's never clear
who's in on Marisa's imposture -- or why -- so all the revelations and
confrontations come off like foggy introductions at a dull cocktail party. And
in a desperate attempt to fudge stereotype, Wang makes Marisa's son, Ty (Tyler
Garcia Posey), a fan of Richard Nixon and the liberal, womanizing Marshall a
Republican. As for whether J. Lo can act, she looks equally hot in a maid's
uniform and a $5000 Dolce & Gabbana suit -- and equally uncomfortable. (97
minutes) At the Entertainment, Flagship, Opera House, Providence Place Mall
16, Showcase, and Tri-Boro cinemas.
Issue Date: December 13 - 19, 2002
|