A movie for the millennium
Why Metropolis is the matrix of all cinema
BY JEFFREY GANTZ
Metropolis. Directed by Fritz Lang. Screenplay by Fritz Lang and Thea von Harbou. With
Brigitte Helm, Alfred Abel, Gustav Fröhlich, Rudolf Klein-Rogge, Fritz
Rasp, Theodor Loos, Erwin Biswanger, and Heinrich George. Original musical
score by Gottfried Huppertz performed by Berndt Heller and the Saarland Radio
Symphony. A Kino International release (126 minutes). At the Avon.
Fritz Lang's Metropolis is the Everymovie of the 20th century. It's
mythopoeic, with its core of classical archetype (Ouranos and Kronos, Oedipus,
Orpheus, Pygmalion), Biblical reference (the Flood, the Tower of Babel, Moloch,
the Crucifixion, the Whore of Babylon), and more-contemporary avatars (Joan of
Arc, the Golem, Frankenstein, the Hunchback of Notre Dame, Wagner's
Ring). It's psychoanalytic, with Lord of Metropolis Joh Fredersen and
his rival in love, the inventor Rothwang, locked in love for the dead Hel and
Freder, the son of Joh and Hel, crippled by castration anxiety while Maria, the
only woman of any consequence in the film, gets split into madonna and whore.
It's socio-economic, what with its depiction of the lumpen proletariat as a
gray mass of undifferentiated prison matter living in the bowels of the earth
while far above the Fathers (no Mothers in this movie) create "Eternal Gardens"
for the "Sons" (no Daughters, either). That it's political goes without saying:
over its 75-year history, it's been accused of promoting capitalism, communism,
and fascism. But it's also been a pop-culture fountain of youth, getting raided
by Gene Roddenberry (the "Cloud Minders" episode of Star Trek), George
Lucas (Star Wars), Ridley Scott (Blade Runner), Madonna ("Express
Yourself"), Queen ("Radio Ga Ga"), and many, many more.
In short, Metropolis has everything . . . except a story
line that makes sense and a cast who can act. You could say that about Star
Wars, of course. With all respect to George Lucas, however,
Metropolis isn't just the Everymovie of the 20th century, it's the
Antimovie of the 20th century. Not even Star Wars subverts everyday art
-- or everyday life -- the way Metropolis does.
Yet for decades, it's been a museum piece, a shadow of its real self. About a
fifth of the original has been lost; what remains has been restored to glory by
a German effort led by the Friedrich-Wilhelm-Murnau-Stiftung. It premiered at
the Berlin Film Festival last year (where the audience at the 1700-seat
Berlinale-Palast overflowed into the aisles); now it's being distributed by
Kino International. Barring the unlikely discovery of that lost footage, this
is the best Metropolis you'll ever see, and you can take it all in (plan
to go more than once) at the Avon beginning this Friday.
The history of Metropolis is almost as convoluted as its story line.
Germany's premier film studio, Universum-Film Aktiengesellschaft (Ufa),
conceived it as the movie that would enable German cinema to break into the
American market. Its cost (a staggering four million Reichsmark) was equaled
only by its hype. In its technical and special effects, it was decades ahead of
its time; Hollywood didn't catch up till the computer age. Yet the Berlin
premiere, at the Ufa-Palast am Zoo on January 10, 1927, drew mixed reviews. And
Metropolis's American distributor, Paramount, saw no reason to accord
the film more than two hours of running time, so playwright Channing Pollock
was hired to edit it from 4189 meters down to 3100. Ufa itself was hardly more
optimistic: the version it distributed to the home market was just 3241 meters.
(It's difficult to talk about these lengths in terms of time because we're not
sure what speed the film was being shown at.) Even the original pruned-down
negatives appear to be lost; the various versions that have survived include
the 1984 Giorgio Moroder restoration, trimmed to 80-odd minutes and
sporting a new soundtrack with songs by Freddie Mercury, Pat Benatar,
Bonnie Tyler, Loverboy, and Adam Ant.
This new 3341-meter print has restored a small amount of footage and added
intertitles that describe the missing action. At the Berlin Film Festival, a
live orchestra performed a new score written by Bernd Schultheiss; on the Kino
release, however, Berndt Heller leads the Saarland Radio Symphony in Gottfried
Huppertz's 1927 score for piano or small orchestra, which underlines the action
without being literal or obtrusive (the plainchant Dies Irae gets a workout).
The Berlinale program book gives the running time as 2:26:30 at 20 frames per
second; the Avon will be screening its print at 24 frames per second (which
looks hurried only when characters are in quick motion) for a running time of
about 2:06.
The 100 or so meters of extra footage provide small but significant additions.
We first see Freder in what, lined with classical statuary, anticipates the
Olympic Stadium built for the 1936 Berlin Games, with Aryan-looking young men
(no women) training for the 200-meter dash. When our hero, in white silk shirt
and jodhpurs, does turn up at the "Club of the Sons" in the "Eternal Gardens,"
scantily clad ladies of the evening compete for his attention, since in
Metropolis the role of women is to please men. Later, we learn that Rothwang's
real goal is not the creation of the perfect machine worker but revenge on Joh
Fredersen, who had a son by the woman Rothwang was in love with; Hel died in
giving birth to Freder, and Rothwang has created a memorial to her memory. The
added intertitles give weight to Freder's bond with dismissed official Josaphat
and Worker 11811 (the one for whom Freder takes over at the "clock" machine);
we also see Robot Maria in a slinky black dress driving men wild in the
Yoshiwara pleasure quarter. The plot, such as it is, becomes a little clearer,
but the real gain is the digital restoration of the image: what was fuzzy and
indecipherable even on DVD now pops out at you in crisp black-and-white.
And it's the image that's the message in Metropolis. Although the new
print makes the histrionic acting -- especially by plucked-from-the-extras
Gustav Fröhlich as Freder and 17-year-old Brigitte Helm as Maria/Robot
Maria -- seem more competent, acting isn't the point here, any more than it is
in Star Wars. Metropolis is about archetypes, and Lang's are even
bigger than Lucas's. Joh (Johann, also Jehovah) Fredersen is the
castrating/castrated Father/Dictator who rules from the Olympian heights of the
penthouse office in the New Tower of Babylon; bereaved of the Mother, he tries
to flood his Creation and start over. The Son of this God, Freder, holds Worker
11811 in a pietà position before taking over the "clock" machine and
himself being crucified on the dial of time; afterward he descends Orpheus-like
into the catacombs of Metropolis to restore the Maiden/Mother to the world. And
though the sight of the Father embracing the Maiden/Mother (actually it's Robot
Maria) sends him into an Oedipal convulsion, he recovers in time to help the
Maiden/Mother save God's children from the Flood. Lucifer figure Rothwang would
replace the Father as the Creator; he's Pygmalion, Frankenstein, the Golem, the
Hunchback, the Monster/Bad Father from whom the Maiden must be rescued by the
Son, the Dæmonic Energy that must be destroyed. (The actor, Rudolf
Klein-Rogge, is Lang's Dr. Mabuse and also the Mabuse-like Haghi in
Spies.) Maria, in addition to being Maiden and Mother, is John the
Baptist baptizing Freder as the Mediator/Messiah. Robot Maria is the Whore of
Babylon as she rises almost naked out of a salver decorated by the Whore's
seven heads and supported by the Seven Deadly Sins from the Cathedral of
Metropolis; when the mob turns against her, she becomes Joan of Arc.
The matrices of Metropolis, however, are the City and the Robot (just
look at the posters). Metropolis is all vertical, a Pyramid erected by Hebrew
slaves for the Egyptians, a Valhalla built by the giants for the Norse gods.
Like the Tower of Babel, it aspires to Heaven, but its roots reach down to
Hell. Men rule the penthouse, women the catacombs; buried in between are the
gargoyle-studded Cathedral and, opposite, Rothwang's Gothic gingerbread house.
The Robot (before Rothwang turns her into Maria) is annunciated by the pumping
ziggurat pistons that kick-start Metropolis: she's technology and
sexuality -- especially female sexuality -- out of control. (Remember the cone
breasts of Madonna's "Blond Ambition" Tour?) For Rothwang and Joh Fredersen,
she's the ultimate fetish, the immortal image of a dead woman and thus the
perfect receptacle of voyeuristic and narcissistic love; but when as Robot
Maria she threatens to eat men the way the Moloch-like machines of Metropolis
eat workers, the easily swayed mob (anticipating Lang's M and
Fury) burns her as a witch, and the melting of her flesh redefines her
as Metropolis's fondest hope and greatest fear, the Machine in the Garden.
What finality could frame this fearful asymmetry? Metropolis concludes
with Freder acting as the mediating "heart" between the "head" of the
privileged and the "hands" of the workers as he persuades Joh Fredersen and
machine foreman Groth to shake hands in front of the empty icon of the
Cathedral while the workers robot-shuffle the way they did at the movie's
beginning. Of course it's not convincing. And though Lang and his wife, Thea
von Harbou, may have believed in their ending at the time, Metropolis
isn't the only Lang film that wraps up in a perfunctory way. Spencer Tracy's
day in court at the end of Fury lasts hardly a minute; George Raft and
Sylvia Sidney become parents in less time than that at the end of You and
Me; and then there's the return-to-kill-Hitler epilogue of Man Hunt,
the honeymoon epilogue of Ministry of Fear, and the Mexican-patio
epilogue of Secret Beyond the Door. Lang's endings don't provide answers
any more than his films tell stories. Metropolis is to ordinary movies
what antimatter is to matter; the mystery is why Ufa marketed it as a movie for
the masses. Made to explore and not just to entertain, it's the movie that for
75 years now has challenged what movies are all about.
Issue Date: November 1 - 7, 2002
|