Love story
Zhang Yimou takes the road home to love
BY JEFFREY GANTZ
The Road Home; Directed by Zhang Yimou. Written by Bao Shi, from his novel Remembrance.
With Zhang Ziyi, Zheng Hao, Sun Honglei, Zhao Yuelin, and Li Bin. A Sony
Classics release. In Mandarin with English subtitles. At the Avon.
The road from the city leads the narrator through the prairie and back to the
village where he was born. He's returning to make arrangements for the funeral
of his father, who died after being caught far away in a snowstorm. It turns
out that his mother wants her husband's coffin borne home in the traditional
way, on foot, but there are hardly any young men left in the village -- they've
all moved to the city. While he's pondering how to fulfill his mother's wish,
he reflects on how his parents met, some 40 years earlier, and it's this
flashback to their courtship that constitutes the body of Zhang Yimou's The
Road Home.
Sounds a little like The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance -- and indeed,
Zhang's Silver Bear winner from last year's Berlin Film Fest could be a John
Ford Western. It has in Sanhetun a small, poor North China village inhabited by
ordinary men (just two women in the movie) who are unsophisticated and not
overbright but goodhearted, which for Ford is what counts. It has Ford's
respect for traditional values. And it has a love story that's the more
powerful for being stripped to essentials, the kind you don't find in Pearl
Harbor or Moulin Rouge.
The Road Home likewise recalls John Ford in its deceptive simplicity.
Zhang films the long flashback segment in kaleidoscopic color (Hou Yong is the
cinematographer) but the contemporary frame in a grainy black-and-white. That's
his comment on the anonymity of modern-day China, but he may also be suggesting
that life remembered (or imagined) sometimes takes on colors it didn't have
when it was experienced. Then there's his choice of Panavision: it seems the
wrong shape for a love story, but when he closes in on Zhao Di or Luo Changyu,
he's reminding us that it takes two persons to fill a widescreen frame.
Changyu (Zheng Hao) is the 20-year-old schoolteacher who's come to Sanhetun
because he couldn't find work in the city. Pigtailed 18-year-old Di (Zhang Ziyi
-- no relation to the director), the most beautiful girl in the village, has
rejected all offers of an arranged marriage (that being the norm then), but she
falls for him at first sight; she loves even the sound of his voice as he
teaches, though she has no interest in going to school. Their first meetings
are the aw-shucks foot-scuffing kind. Di starts drawing water from the well
that's farther from the village but close to the school, and when Changyu comes
to dinner (the villagers take turns feeding him), she rustles up her best
dishes. She also weaves the red banner that's hung from the school rafters for
good luck. Seeing her at the well, he tries to draw water himself so he can
talk to her, and when he's called away for unspecified political reasons, he
gives her a barrette to go with her red quilted jacket.
Changyu leaves so suddenly that he misses out on the mushroom dumplings Di had
made for him, so she wraps them up and goes running after the horse cart, as if
she could overtake it by sheer force of will (or through, as in run-of-the-mill
American Westerns, directorial deus ex machina). She can't, of course,
and neither does standing out in the snow and waiting on the day he's expected
to return bring him back. In desperation, Di pulls on her boots and tries to
trek to the city (probably days away on foot), but she collapses by the
roadside and has to be carried back home with a high fever. Her determination
is a kind of obsessiveness: like the 13-year-old substitute teacher Wei Minzhi
in Zhang's previous film, Not One Less, she keeps trying to make reality
conform to her wishes, and Zhang doesn't portray this stubbornness as an
unmitigated virtue. Minzhi isn't always likable, but her persistence pays off
when a city TV station finds her missing student (and in the process helps
itself to big ratings). Di triumphs for a better reason: Changyu loves her.
Although the bureaucrats aren't finished with him, he returns to the village to
see her; his unauthorized departure results in a two- year delay before they're
allowed to marry.
Like the courtship of Wyatt Earp and Clementine Carter in My Darling
Clementine, or Michael O'Rourke and Philadelphia Thursday in Fort
Apache, this is primal, idealistic stuff. Di and Changyu know as little
about each other as we know about them; there are no compatibility profiles or
computer match-ups here, just two young persons with nothing in common beyond
their eagerness to please each other. And Zhang would have us believe that's
enough. What the nuances of their shy-but-hopeful facial expressions don't tell
us, his cinematography does. Di is most often seen in a pink quilted jacket,
but the red one is Changyu's favorite (no subtlety in Zhang's color symbolism);
and when she's framed by yellow-flowering birches (a traditional symbol of
fidelity) as she watches Changyu from a distance, there's no need to say more.
San Bao's score, with its low flutes, is discreet; often the soundtrack gives
us nothing more than a whisper of wind. It's love and filmmaking at their most
basic.
Back in the black-and-white present, Luo Yusheng (Sun Honglei) has hauled out
his mother's old loom -- the only one left in the village -- so that she can
weave a cloth for her husband's coffin, just as she did for his school. Yusheng
has also decided to pay 36 men from nearby villages to carry the coffin -- but
when word gets out, some hundred of his father's old students turn up (from as
far away as Guangzhou), and they won't accept any money. It's a Ford touch, the
common people rising to the occasion, and so is the long shot of the funeral
procession that snakes through the snowy landscape, man dwarfed by nature but
ennobled by the esteem of his fellow men. The money that would have paid for
this procession instead goes toward building a new school, but not even that
gesture is enough to make the film bloom with color. And when the now old Di
(Zhao Yuelin) tells Yusheng how much they missed him, you begin to realize that
he hasn't been the ideal son, disinclined to follow in his father's footsteps
(he seems to be in business), too busy to visit or write, too busy to find a
girlfriend. By tradition, everyone along the funeral-procession route yells at
the coffin so the deceased won't forget the road home, but here it's Changyu's
son who's lost his way.
So in the final sequence, Yusheng does what his mother says will make his
father happy: he teaches a day of school. This won't change his life, but it
enables Di to hear her husband again. And that does push the film back into
color, the young Di in her red jacket running down the yellow-lined road once
more, the road that leads us home to love.
Issue Date: September 7 - 13, 2001
|