HEALTH-CARE PRIORITIES
AIDS groups grapple with a mixed message
BY LORI COLE
Although preliminary reports from the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention (CDC) show that the number of new AIDS cases in the US
increased last year by eight percent, AIDS organizations are being forced to
increase services with less funding. "We have been able to help everyone who
comes to us for care," says Chris Butler, executive director of AIDS Project
Rhode Island (APRI), "but we fear we will not be able to in the future if there
is no increase in funding."
The Bush Administration has flat-funded for two years the Ryan White CARE Act,
which funds local governments and organizations that care for people affected
by HIV/AIDS. And although the administration allocated more HIV/AIDS money in
the 2003 budget, support for abstinence-only programs was increased by 33
percent.
"Obviously, abstinence is the best method for preventing HIV," says Butler,
"but we know, after doing this for 20 years, that that is not a message that
works for everybody." A study conducted for Congress by the Mathematica Policy
Research Institute found no evidence that abstinence-only programs prevent teen
sex, pregnancy, or disease. Meanwhile, methods that mention abstinence with
contraceptives are medically proven as effective, according to the Alan
Guttmacher Institute. But Butler, who already has to consult the Rhode Island
Department of Health whenever APRI creates a brochure or poster with explicit
content, says, "I fear that in the future, federal-funded programs will only
let us promote abstinence."
HIV/AIDS organizations fear a national a backlash against prevention programs
because of recent reports by DC-based Citizens Against Government Waste (CAGW),
which cites instances of "waste, fraud, abuse, and mismanagement of federal
AIDS funds." But while CAGW recommends cutting funding for HIV-prevention
programs with sexual content, prevention organizations cites this material as
an important part of getting the message across to a sexually active
audience.
APRI is focusing its advocacy and prevention efforts on reaching minorities,
because of the high incidence of HIV and AIDS in men and women in the
African-American, Latino, and Asian-American communities. While race and
ethnicity are not risk factors in themselves, they sometimes combine with
limited economic resources and unequal access to health-care to cause the more
frequent incidence. "This is why APRI's services are so valuable," notes
Butler. "We would love to do a statewide campaign on billboards and buses, but
there really isn't enough money. So we target very specific groups and
programs."
Issue Date: May 24 - 30 2002
|