You could say it all started with a well-known blonde named Martha.
She cooked, she cleaned, she crafted -- and a generation adopted her as their
household-artist inspiration. Over the past 10 years, Martha Stewart has become
not only a cultural icon but a mentor for many who aspire to her seamless blend
of easy elegance, business savvy, and unrelenting resourcefulness.
But Martha Stewart and her empire stand at the beginning of the story. These
days, gray-haired grandma is also a font of domestic inspiration. At the turn
of this young century, tying on an apron suddenly became a voguish fashion
statement, meat loaf shed its irony, and grandma's thrifty advice suddenly acquired new
relevance.
Call it the comeback of Cold War culture, a fascination with the '50s, a
hankering for homemaking, all spurred on by stifling the subversive. As the
threat of terrorist attacks menaces our well-being, and the government deems
"civil liberties" a gray area and regards people not fruuum here sketchy
enough to interrogate and deport, cultural trends harking back 50 years have
taken new hold on the American imagination.
It's Donna Reed and June Cleaver. It's Grease and Elvis. It's kitsch,
but it's now cool in a less ironic way. And if young folks have thus far dipped
only their toes into the trend, get ready for their full immersion in 2002. The
scariness of the current war, along with the fear aroused by the government's
newfound heavy-handedness, has catalyzed a trend that had already been seeping
into our kitchens, our homes, and our lifestyles. Afraid of
the world? Bake a pie. Can't speak out about how you don't really feel
patriotic? Knit a sweater and keep quiet. And hey, go reinvigorate the economy
already!
THE SIMILARITIES -- both political and cultural -- verge on the eerie.
In 1953, back when the Soviet Union was Public Enemy Number One, social
theorist David Reisman -- author of The Lonely Crowd: A Study of the
Changing American Character (Yale University Press, 1950) -- spoke at an
academic conference on the subject of totalitarianism. He proposed launching a
full-on "nylon war" -- literally bombarding the Soviet Union with stockings and
other consumer goods in order to make friends with its citizens and encourage
their alienation from Communism. Today in Afghanistan, the US government is
substituting grain for consumer goods, dropping dinner for starving Afghans
along with cluster bombs. But the inescapable irony of simultaneously killing
and feeding, threatening and gifting, remains.
One of the most disturbing intellectual trends of the '50s was the blacklisting
of writers, artists, and performers working in Hollywood. Names of filmmakers
suspected of smuggling subversive pro-USSR, pro-Communist thoughts onto
celluloid were placed on a secret list circulated throughout the entertainment
industry, which flushed their careers down the proverbial toilet. Five years
ago, the idea of the blacklist was widely condemned as something marking the
darker side of another era. Today, not so. Second Lady Lynne Cheney, for one,
hopes to revive a '50s-era muzzle -- this time, in the ivory tower rather than
Hollywood. Last month, Cheney, one of the founding members of the aggressively
conservative nonprofit watchdog group American Council of Trustees and Alumni,
stirred up controversy when the group took scholars, students, and university
presidents to task for making unpatriotic statements. The organization compiled
a list of what it deemed egregious anti-American statements made by academics
and posted it on its Web site (www.goacta.org/Reports/defciv.pdf) under the
heading "Defending Civilization: How Our Universities Are Failing America and
What Can Be Done about It." Some remarks cited in the report were as insidious
as "Ignorance breeds hate," which was the cautionary yet dangerous
thought of Wasima Alikhan of the Islamic Academy of Las Vegas.
In another similarity with the '50s, today's fears of anthrax and terrorist
attacks parallel the atomic anxiety of yesteryear. What University of
Pennsylvania professor Alan Filreis had to say in a 1999 paper on the cultural
aspects of atomic anxiety sounds awfully familiar right now: "Once the bombs
had been dropped, could Americans go on and play ping-pong or poker, go
shopping, shoot cap-pistols in fringed jackets and Dan'l Boone
caps?. . . The normal was no longer normal. Every innocent act had
the potential of the acutest dramatic irony. Every ping-pong game could have
the feel of false innocence, of denial." He quotes from Paul Boyer's 1985 book
By the Bomb's Early Light: American Thought and Culture at the Dawn of the
Atomic Age: "American culture had been profoundly affected by atomic fear,
by a dizzying plethora of atomic panaceas and proposals, and by endless
speculation on the social and ethical implications of the new reality."
ALONG WITH STRONG-ARM politics, threats to civil liberties, and terrific fear
has come a return to domesticity, to the rosy ideal of the warm hearth and
tight-knit family, to wholesome American values.
Witness young women's newfound fascination with knitting, one of the most
striking ways Cold War culture has staged a comeback. Stitch 'n' bitch groups
-- social gatherings of young knitters who assemble under the pretense of
crafting rather than cocktailing -- started popping up last year. But these
days, they've become wildly popular. Contacted on a recent afternoon, Niki
Bronstein, owner of the Harvard Square knitting shop Woolcott & Co., is too
busy to chat. "Business is phenomenal," she says, before rushing off the phone
to tend to the masses. She calls back a few hours later, harried but
enthusiastic. "We have a lot of new-mother knitters," she says. "A lot of the
college kids are knitting. A lot of guys are knitting, too. I think at one time
it used to be older, but now it's younger people." Bronstein leads a weekly
knitting workshop swamped by Gen Xers. "There's hardly ever anyone over 30,"
she marvels. "They're all in mid-to-late 20s. It's catching on."
Jessica Marcus, 25, started working in the store after a stint in the dot-com
world. She counts herself among the newly initiated knitters, but Marcus
believes that she's tapped into "an undercurrent that was already there. The
fact that we are in military action now accentuates the need to feel useful and
find some sort of fulfillment, whether it's getting together with friends and
serving cookies or knitting." Seizing on this rekindled interest in needles and
yarn, Vogue magazine has reissued old pattern books such as Vogue
Knitting on the Go and Vogue Knitting Vintage Knits (both Butterick
Company Inc., 2001), in addition to Vogue Knitting magazine, a staple
for fashionable crafters.
On the fashion front as well, colors, cuts, and styles are increasingly
reminiscent of grandma's garb. British Vogue, ever a forward-thinking
arbiter of across-the-pond fashion, has taken note of the growing fascination
with '50s culture. The November issue features a beauty page announcing the
return of the "Fabulous '50s." "Fashion's tribute to the glamorous Fifties
began last season," it reads. "The Fifties revival occurred virtually overnight
and we all longed to evoke the pin-up girls of that decadent era. Hollywood
glamour and all its trappings was back with a vengeance. . . .
Think Ava Gardner, Brigitte Bardot, and Gina Lollobrigida. What could be more
feminine and sexy than their porcelain skin, cupid's-bow lips, and hourglass
curves?"
Along with the '50s glamour-girl look celebrated by British Vogue comes
the era's flip side: the Iron Curtain look (see photo this page), proclaimed in
a 1952 issue of Life. Both the dramatic couture of voluptuous
old-Hollywood fantasy (think Catherine Zeta-Jones) and the realistic pragmatism
of the severe, Soviet-inspired wardrobe are reappearing on today's racks and
catwalks.
But it's not just what people are wearing that sends a shout-out to the good
old days. It's also what they're doing when they take off those clothes. Sure
enough, fascination with the '50s has also permeated the sexual and
relationship realms. Papers across the country have been peeking into American
bedrooms, eagerly reporting back that people are changing their sexual ways:
Terror sex is in! Divorce is down! Young marriages are up! The sex
industry's still firm!
Whatever the sexual trends, the stories also suggest that young people are
eagerly slipping on rings. In early November, USA Today reported that
"anecdotal evidence across the USA indicates Americans are reaching out to
friends and family and seeking connection since September 11." And the informal
evidence jibes with First Lady Laura Bush's proclamation that "couples are
coming together and staying together. Since September 11, divorce cases have
been withdrawn at higher rates, and more people are buying engagement rings and
planning weddings." Yet to be determined is whether the surge in shacking up,
the slowed-down economy -- necessitating cozy nights at home -- and the
reported increase in sexual activity will spark a new baby boom in the months
and years to come.
THE TANKING ECONOMY and rising unemployment rate, along with the romanticized
notion of homemaking, have also converged in the American kitchen, sparking a
revival of '50s-era comfort food. Au revoir, late-'90s towers of
ethno-fusion-inspired cuisine. These days, it's all about warm, dense, American
grub. In a recent survey conducted by The All New Good Housekeeping
Cookbook (Hearst Books, 2001), the editors report that comfort foods are
returning to the American dinner table, with women's favorites listed as
macaroni and cheese, ice cream, soup, mashed potatoes, candy, meat loaf, and
potato chips. Sure enough, instant-mashed-potatoes sales jumped about 13
percent in September, and snack-food sales increased by about 12 percent, the
Associated Press reported in early November. In the past month, the Boston
Globe has drooled over meat loaf, hearty soup, and baked beans. And
cookbook author Joan Schwartz recently published an ode to an old favorite in
Macaroni & Cheese: 52 Recipes, from Simple to Sublime (Villard
Books, 2001).
Even at upscale eateries around town, diners are forgoing fanciful dishes for
hearty staples. Harvard Square's warm and unpretentious Sandrine's is doing a
mean business with its meaty grab-bag choucroute. "Five years ago," marvels
co-owner Gwen Trost, "no one could believe that we put it on the menu." Another
popular item has been onion soup. "Everybody orders that," Trost says.
It all makes sense to Carolyn Wyman, author of Jell-O:
A Biography (Harvest Books, 2001). She explains that while Jell-O
has actually been around since the turn of the century, "the height of Jell-O
consumption -- when it reached its highest expression -- was in the '50s,
during a postwar convenience-food cooking craze." Wyman reports that a Jell-O
plant in Dover, Delaware, has been operating around the clock recently:
"They're flat out selling Jell-O."
Wyman counts the jiggly stuff as comfort food. "It's served in diners, that
kind of a place where it's real, real food, not this fancy stuff that
you don't understand," she says. "I've heard people talk about how cynicism is
out. [Jell-O's]
real honest." In fact, Wyman sees Jell-O
as the perfect synthesis of '50s throwback and '00s modernity. "It is
comforting and nostalgic, but at the same time it's not heavy. So it's like, we
can still eat it and live the lifestyles we do now."
IF YOUR GRANDMA is not around to share her housekeeping secrets, meat-loaf
recipes, or "how to get a ring -- fast" tips, there's still hope:
magazines have stepped up to the plate to dish out the hotly desired guidance.
One useful and formerly mid-level seller, Time Inc.'s Real Simple, a
lifestyle monthly that focuses on simplifying women's worlds through crafting,
cooking, and organizing, has been thriving post-September 11. The September
issue was its all-time best seller. It makes sense. What could be a more 1950s,
June Cleaver-type cliché than homemade treats and handmade wreathes?
Pass the yarn.
Nina Willdorf can be reached at nwilldorf[a]phx.com..
Issue Date: January 4 - 10, 2002